Live Bait Vs. Artificial Bait: Which Is Best?

Fishing baits and rod isolated on wooden background

The debate between live bait and artificial lures has been ongoing as long as anglers have cast lines. Both have their own advantages, and what works best often depends on various factors, including the type of fish you’re after, the conditions, and personal preference.

Let’s dive into the merits of each to help you decide which bait might be best for your next fishing expedition!

Advantages of Live Bait

Natural Appeal: Nothing can replicate the movement, smell, and feel of live bait. This natural allure can be irresistible to fish, increasing the likelihood of a bite.

Versatility: Different fish prefer different diets. With live bait, you can choose from a variety of options, such as worms, minnows, or insects, depending on your target fish.

Ideal for Beginners: For those new to fishing, live bait can be more forgiving, offering better chances of attracting fish even if the technique isn’t perfect.

Advantages of Artificial Bait

Durability: Artificial lures can last much longer than live bait. There’s no need to worry about them dying or becoming less lively over time.

Wide Range of Options: From colourful spinners to lifelike swimbaits, the array of artificial baits allows anglers to experiment and find the perfect lure for any situation.

Environmentally Friendly: Over-harvesting live bait from natural habitats can be ecologically detrimental. Artificial baits don’t have the same environmental concerns.

Less Mess: Live bait can be slimy, messy, and difficult to handle. Artificial lures provide a cleaner alternative, especially for those who are squeamish.

Which Should You Choose?

The choice between live and artificial bait often boils down to the specific conditions of your fishing outing. Here are a few tips:

  • For clear water and skittish fish, live bait might be more effective.
  • In murkier waters, bright, noisy artificial lures can be better at attracting fish.
  • Consider local regulations. Some locations may have restrictions on using live bait.
  • For beginner fishermen, live bait might be the best option since you can simply drop your line and wait for fish to bite. Lures typically take a learning curve.
  • Using a lure can help you attract particular types of fish. Since all fish are attracted to live bait, you can end up catching species you aren’t interested in. 
  • Always keep both options in your tackle box for a big fishing excursion. Being adaptable is key in fishing!

When considering the bait debate, remember that both live and artificial baits have their place in an angler’s arsenal. Experimentation is often the best way to determine which is right for you.

Now that you have some tips for choosing between baits and lures, it’s time to book a stay at Lawrence Bay Lodge. Enjoy a few peaceful days fishing on Reindeer Lake with our top-of-the-line equipment, knowledgeable guides, comfortable rooms, and home-cooked food that can’t be beat!

Call us today at (701)262-4560 or fill out our contact form online to receive more information on planning your next fishing trip in Northern Saskatchewan.